Home › Guides › Can a Roofer Pay or Give Discounts for Google Reviews?
Can a Roofer Pay or Give Discounts for Google Reviews?
Short answer: No. A roofer cannot pay, discount or give free work for Google reviews. Google's Maps policy bans incentives of any kind and removes reviews posted because of one. The FTC rule, in force since October 2024, also bans buying fake reviews and rewards tied to a positive review. Ask every customer for an honest review instead.
- Google's Maps policy bans payment, discounts, free goods or services in exchange for reviews.
- Google says incentivized reviews will be removed from Maps.
- The FTC rule on fake reviews went into effect on October 21, 2024.
- The FTC bans incentives tied to a review saying something positive or negative, stated or implied.
- Google bars merchants from selectively asking only happy customers for reviews.
A homeowner just got a new roof. You hand them the invoice and say, "Leave us a five-star review and I'll knock $100 off." It feels like a fair trade. It is not allowed on Google, and depending on how you word it, it can break a federal rule too. This guide sets out what Google bans, what the FTC rule adds and how to get reviews the safe way.
A review incentive is anything of value you offer a customer in return for writing a review. That includes cash, gift cards, a discount on the job, a free gutter cleaning, a free inspection or a raffle entry.
What does Google say about paying for reviews?
Google's rules for Maps content, which cover Business Profile reviews, are plain. Paid reviews, "directly or in kind," count as fake engagement. The same policy says offering incentives "such as payment, discounts, free goods and/or services" for reviews is prohibited, and that incentivized reviews "will be removed from Maps."
That covers more than cash. For a roofer, it rules out:
- "$100 off your roof if you leave a review."
- A free gutter guard or a free annual inspection for a review.
- Entering reviewers in a drawing for a gift card.
- Paying a review service to post reviews for you.
- Offering a refund if the customer changes or deletes a bad review.
The last one is in the policy too. Google bans incentives for changing or removing a negative review.
What does the FTC fake review rule say?
In August 2024, the FTC announced a final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials. The FTC's Q&A page says the rule went into effect on October 21, 2024. Here is what it covers, in plain words:
- Fake reviews. Reviews from people who do not exist or never had a real experience with you, including AI-generated fake reviews. Buying them is banned too.
- Sentiment-based rewards. Offering money or a reward on the condition that the review is positive, or negative, whether you say it outright or imply it.
- Insider reviews. Reviews by your officers or managers that do not disclose the connection.
- Review suppression. Using baseless legal threats, physical threats or intimidation to stop or remove negative reviews.
- Fake social proof. Buying or selling fake followers or views.
The FTC says it can seek civil penalties against people who knowingly break the rule.
Is any incentive allowed under the FTC rule?
This is where roofers get confused. The FTC's own Q&A says "the rule does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews," as long as you do not state or imply that the review must be positive or negative.
But that does not make it OK on Google. Google's Maps policy still bans incentives for Google reviews, full stop. So on Google, the stricter rule wins. Here is how the two line up.
| What you do | Google Maps policy | FTC rule |
|---|---|---|
| Ask every customer for an honest review, no reward | Allowed | Allowed |
| Offer $50 off for any review, good or bad | Not allowed, review removed | Not banned by the rule itself |
| Offer $50 off for a five-star review | Not allowed | Banned |
| Buy reviews or post fake ones | Not allowed | Banned |
| Ask only customers you think are happy | Not allowed | No specific ban, but could violate the FTC Act |
| Have your office manager review you without saying so | Not allowed (conflict of interest) | Banned for undisclosed insider reviews |
| Threaten to sue over an honest bad review | Not allowed to discourage reviews | Banned if the threat is baseless |
Sources: Google Maps contribution policy, FTC rule announcement and FTC Q&A. This is a plain summary, not legal advice.
Can a roofer ask only happy customers?
No. Picking who gets the review link is called review gating. Google bars merchants from ["selectively solicit[ing] positive reviews from customers"](https://support.google.com/contributionpolicy/answer/7400114). The FTC's Q&A says its rule has no specific ban on this practice, but "this practice could violate the FTC Act."
So the same request goes to the homeowner who loved the new roof and the one who argued about the dumpster on their lawn. Some review tools ask a "how did we do?" question first and only send happy customers to Google. Do not set yours up that way.
Can employees or family review a roofing company?
Google's Maps policy bars conflict-of-interest content, such as reviews based on current or former employment or a contractual relationship. So your crew, your sales reps and your office staff should not review your business on Google.
The FTC Q&A says employees may write reviews if the relationship is clearly disclosed. It also says a business is not liable for an employee's false review that came from a general request to all buyers. That is the federal rule. Google's own policy is stricter, so keep staff off your Google reviews.
Can a roofing contract ban bad reviews?
No. The FTC explains that under the Consumer Review Fairness Act, it is illegal in form contracts to bar or restrict customers from reviewing you, to charge or fine them for a review, or to claim rights over their review content. The FTC says to remove such clauses from form contracts and online terms even if you never used them. Check your roofing contract template and your website terms.
How should a roofer get reviews the right way?
Ask everyone, the same way, with nothing in return. That is it.
- Get your Google review link from your Business Profile and test it on your phone.
- Ask after the job is finished, the yard is clean and the dumpster is gone.
- Send the same text to every customer, including the grumpy ones.
- Follow up once a week later, then stop.
- Reply to every review, good or bad.
A neutral ask sounds like this:
Hi [First name], this is [Your name] from [Company]. Thanks for having us work on your roof. Would you leave an honest Google review? Here is the link: [link]. Reply STOP to opt out.
Our roofing review request texts give versions for repairs, storm jobs and inspections. For what to say when a bad one comes in, read how a roofer should respond to a bad review.
Why do roofers feel pushed to pay for reviews?
Because reviews matter, and roofers know it. Google lists review count and rating as inputs to prominence, one of the three main things behind local results. Homeowners comparing three roofers after a storm look at stars first.
Think of a labeled example. A new roofer in Boise, Idaho, has 9 reviews and competes with companies that have hundreds. It is tempting to buy a batch. But bought reviews can be removed, and a profile that loses a pile of reviews at once looks worse than one that grew slowly. A steady habit of asking every customer gets you there without the risk. Our guide on how many Google reviews a roofer needs helps you set a target based on the roofers near you.
What about storm and insurance jobs?
Be extra careful here. Never tie a review to anything about the claim, the deductible or the insurer's check. Some states restrict what roofers can promise about deductibles. Texas, for example, makes it illegal for a contractor to offer to waive, rebate or absorb a deductible. Our Colorado roofing page and our guide on roofer Google Business Profile tips cover the insurance wording to avoid. Ask for the review after the work is done, the same way you ask every other customer.
The hub guide on contractor review examples shows how other trades word their asks. If you want a roofing website that shows your real Google reviews next to your work, you can see a free demo site.
Common questions
Can I give a customer a gift card for a Google review?
No. Google's Maps policy bans incentives for reviews, including payment and free goods or services, and removes reviews posted because of one. A gift card counts. Thank the customer and ask for an honest review with nothing attached.
Is it legal to offer a discount for any review, good or bad?
The FTC rule bans rewards tied to the review being positive or negative, and its Q&A says it does not ban all incentives. Google's policy still bans any incentive for Google reviews, so the review can be removed. On Google, do not offer one.
What happens if Google finds paid reviews on my roofing profile?
Google says incentivized reviews will be removed from Maps. Losing many reviews at once hurts how your profile looks to homeowners. If you have run a review promotion before, stop it now and ask customers the neutral way from here on.
Can my crew leave reviews for my roofing company?
Not on Google. Google's Maps policy bars content based on current or former employment. The FTC allows employee reviews only with clear disclosure, but Google's rule is stricter.
Can I ask a customer to update a bad review after I fix the problem?
You can fix the problem and reply to the review explaining what you did. Do not offer a refund, discount or anything else in return for changing or removing it. Google's Maps policy bans incentives for that.
Sources
- Google Maps contribution policy: Prohibited and restricted content (2026)
- FTC: Final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials (2024)
- FTC: Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule, questions and answers (2024)
- FTC: Consumer Review Fairness Act, what businesses need to know
- Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking (2026)
- Texas Department of Insurance: Roofing and insurance, know the law (2026)
We build your new website free, before you pay, then work every week to get you named when homeowners ask Google and AI who to call. Get your free demo site.